Wednesday, March 18, 2020

Wood or steel?


 Autos of beauty



For today (Thursday):

I am a wood loving guy. I love to smell a saw mill.  I enjoy fireplaces and outside fires. I just completed a nice fire pit for our dead falls here on our acre.
Once while in the building industry I was approached with some other builders and agreed to attend classes near Atlanta at their expense, to explain the need for and use of steel studs in our homes.
The big advantages pushed were: metal is always straight (no warping), lightweight and termite free; all very true.
It was sort of a paid vacation for us, and we had time to talk among ourselves. No one I talked with was willing to switch to metal in residential construction.
 
I have never been convinced that metal is better for the environment vs wood.  Wood is a renewal resource and we have actually made great strides in replenishing our forests in the USA. Every metal stud takes from the non-renewable resources.
PLUS--- we carpenter-types take a lot of retraining to totally use metal saws, screws and screw guns.
In the USA replenish 42% more trees than we harvest. And that doesn’t count Rick & Jilda! The rest of the world isn’t doing so well but are doing better. I read where they are trying but still cut a third more than they renew.
All materials to create the metal stud are Non renewable natural resources. Including the oxygen used by the furnaces.

Now in cars, wood & Steel worked well in years past!
 
Sorry to bore you with carpenter stuff it was just on my mind as I work on the basement bathroom.

Nite Shipslog                       
PS: Facts from the web if you want to read them.
 Taken from the web:
WOOD: The U.S. has 8% of the total forests in the world, and reached a point in 1997 where growth  “exceeded harvest by 42%” and we were growing forests at a rate of roughly four times faster than we were in 1920, when our chop-happiness began to level out due to environmental and recreational concerns regarding timber harvest…….
Some nonrenewable resources are used in the production of wood studs, they are the electricity and fuel for the saws.
Steel:
The raw materials used to make steel framing include iron ore, limestone (or another source of calcium carbonate), coal, and zinc.
Large quantities of oxygen (separated from ambient air at the steelmaking facility) are also used, and supplemental heat comes from fuel oil or natural gas.

9 comments:

I'm mostly known as 'MA' said...

The only place I can think of that requires the metal studs would be in tall buildings like skyscrapers. The weight of some buildings may require them. Glad you are keeping busy there. Nice to hae a bathroom in the basement. Glad we are doing a good job of replanting. Our trees are so important/

betty said...

Very good points you bring up Jack! I hadn't thought about this before. Building things that will last the test of time should be top priority I think over what is used. But then I am not a builder.

Betty

Chatty Crone said...

Okay going back to yesterday's post - are you going to get tested? I bet you were exposed. Just cause I am worried about y'all.

Susan Kane said...

People are thinking of steel supports in their house. Earthquakes, I guess. Would certainly be long lasting.

Mevely317 said...


I never knew this might be a 'thing'! Like Ma, I immediately thought of skyscrapers … remembering the eerie, erect remains of the World Trade Center. Too, wouldn't homeowners (fire) insurance costs be far less?
This aging student still has lots to learn!

Rick Watson said...

We're doing our part Jack :) But I agree with you on wood vs metal. Like you, I love the smell of wood and I love that it's renewable.

Know this, you will never bore me writing about carpentry.

R

Lisa said...

Hmmm never thought about it but some good points here.
It amazes me how they are building 4 story apartments with thin wood and pressboard now days.

Happy Friday
Lisa

Woody said...

Always loved saw mills, saw dust, lucky we had 2 saw mills on the river road in Edwards. Alfred Webb made a living sawing lumber. His wife Libby raised abandoned cats. People drove by their house and would drop off kittens. I do not like Metal Studs, wood studs are the way to build ! Glad your puttering on the basement, That's where I am going today as it is really windy, 61 degrees and raining ! You and your Honey stay Healthy !! Love, Gary an Anna Mae

Leslie Ceaser said...

I will recommend anyone looking for Business loan to Le_Meridian they helped me with Four Million USD loan to startup my Quilting business and it's was fast When obtaining a loan from them it was surprising at how easy they were to work with. They can finance up to the amount of $500,000.000.00 (Five Hundred Million Dollars) in any region of the world as long as there 1.9% ROI can be guaranteed on the projects.The process was fast and secure. It was definitely a positive experience.Avoid scammers on here and contact Le_Meridian Funding Service On. lfdsloans@lemeridianfds.com / lfdsloans@outlook.com. WhatsApp...+ 19893943740. if you looking for business loan.